Moderationpolicy - Гісторыя версій

Sourisdudesert: /* Penalty Grid */

2019-11-27T15:33:17Z

Penalty Grid

@@ Радок 139: / Радок 139: @@
   | For secondary accounts: ban forever. For main account: ELO reseted to 1500 / ELO penalty for all games.
   |-
- ! Something else
   |}

Sourisdudesert: /* Penalty Grid */

2019-11-27T15:32:52Z

Penalty Grid

← Папярэдн. версія		Версія ад 17:32, 27 лістапада 2019
Радок 121:		Радок 121:
	\| Kingmaking action during a game		\| Kingmaking action during a game
	\| As 99% of kingmaking reports are not accurate enough, we are not ignoring Kingmaking report (and now there are closed automatically). Instead, we've add a "Kingmaking / team play" red thumb category, and we must incite players to use this (Red Thumbs) instead of report these players to moderation.		\| As 99% of kingmaking reports are not accurate enough, we are not ignoring Kingmaking report (and now there are closed automatically). Instead, we've add a "Kingmaking / team play" red thumb category, and we must incite players to use this (Red Thumbs) instead of report these players to moderation.
			\| (no penalty)
	\|-		\|-
	! Bug exploit		! Bug exploit
Радок 127:		Радок 128:
	\| No penalty applies: if there is a bug that has been widely used for a game, a global ELO reset (or an ELO adjustment for players who exploited the bug) will be done.		\| No penalty applies: if there is a bug that has been widely used for a game, a global ELO reset (or an ELO adjustment for players who exploited the bug) will be done.
	\|-		\|-
	! Private information		! Private information / slow to play / ruin a game
	\| Some player ~~gives~~ some private information ~~during the game~~		\| Some player ruins a game by giving some private information, was slow to play or played anyhow
	\| ~~Players have the right to pretend things during a game.~~ As ~~these infos could be true or false, and could be exploited by other players too, moderators should be cautious when judging these cases. This case concerns players that had~~ a ~~strong intent to kill~~ the ~~pleasure~~ of the game ~~by giving some private information during~~ the ~~game~~.		\| As long a they respect the rules of the game, anything that can happen is subjective and is out of the scope of Terms of Use. Players should use the Red Thumb system to punish their opponents if they think this is needed.
	~~\| -1 to -10 reputation penalty. Moderators~~ should ~~warn~~ the ~~player that~~ this is ~~a only small warning. Relapses can lead to higher reputation points penalties~~.		\| (no penalty)
	\|-		\|-
	! Multiple accounts		! Multiple accounts

Sourisdudesert: /* Player Profile Influence */

2019-11-27T15:27:56Z

Player Profile Influence

← Папярэдн. версія		Версія ад 17:27, 27 лістапада 2019
Радок 59:		Радок 59:
	* Player is registered for a long time / has a lot of games played.		* Player is registered for a long time / has a lot of games played.
	* Players is involved in the website (ex: realized translations).		* Players is involved in the website (ex: realized translations).
	* Player is supporting BGA (member ~~of the club~~).		* Player is supporting BGA (Premium member).

	You should also take into account the profile of the reporting player (report author) : a bad reputation and/or an important number of reports already judged as "not guilty" should incite you to be very careful with this player report.		You should also take into account the profile of the reporting player (report author) : a bad reputation and/or an important number of reports already judged as "not guilty" should incite you to be very careful with this player report.

Sourisdudesert: /* Appeal */

2019-11-27T15:26:12Z

Appeal

← Папярэдн. версія		Версія ад 17:26, 27 лістапада 2019
Радок 14:		Радок 14:
	Players have the right to appeal against the moderation decision by forwarding received moderation email to "contact+appeal@boardgamearena.com".		Players have the right to appeal against the moderation decision by forwarding received moderation email to "contact+appeal@boardgamearena.com".

	They '''MUST''' explain in the email how the moderator did not follow the BGA Moderation Policy. If the explanation is not convincing, the email will be ignored. If the player is obviously guilty and if the Moderation Policy hasn't been violated, BGA admins will ~~double~~ the ~~penalty~~.		They '''MUST''' explain in the email how the moderator did not follow the BGA Moderation Policy. If the explanation is not convincing, the email will be ignored. If the player is obviously guilty and if the Moderation Policy hasn't been violated, BGA admins will give a more severe penalty than the initial.

	=== Penalty Grid ===		=== Penalty Grid ===

Sourisdudesert: /* Appeal */

2019-11-27T15:25:31Z

Appeal

← Папярэдн. версія		Версія ад 17:25, 27 лістапада 2019
Радок 12:		Радок 12:
	=== Appeal ===		=== Appeal ===

	Players have the right to appeal against the moderation decision by forwarding received moderation email to "contact@boardgamearena.com".		Players have the right to appeal against the moderation decision by forwarding received moderation email to "contact+appeal@boardgamearena.com".

	They '''MUST''' explain in the email how the moderator did not follow the BGA Moderation Policy. If the explanation is not convincing, the email will be ignored. If the player is obviously guilty and if the Moderation Policy hasn't been violated, BGA admins will double the penalty.		They '''MUST''' explain in the email how the moderator did not follow the BGA Moderation Policy. If the explanation is not convincing, the email will be ignored. If the player is obviously guilty and if the Moderation Policy hasn't been violated, BGA admins will double the penalty.

Sourisdudesert: Protected "Moderationpolicy" ([edit=sysop] (indefinite) [move=sysop] (indefinite))

2019-11-27T12:46:15Z

Protected "Moderationpolicy" ([edit=sysop] (indefinite) [move=sysop] (indefinite))

← Папярэдн. версія	Версія ад 14:46, 27 лістапада 2019
(Няма розніцы)

Sourisdudesert: /* Penalty Grid */

2019-02-05T12:00:49Z

Penalty Grid

← Папярэдн. версія		Версія ад 14:00, 5 лютага 2019
Радок 103:		Радок 103:
	2°) This is advertisement / this violate some intellectual property		2°) This is advertisement / this violate some intellectual property
	3°) The avatar contains a reference that discriminate a group of people (ex: nazi cross)		3°) The avatar contains a reference that discriminate a group of people (ex: nazi cross)

			Please also read: [[#Details_on_Avatar_policy]]

	\| Avatar immediate removal + Forbid to chat or publish between 3 days and forever depending on the gravity. In any case: the player should be warn that this is the last warning before ban. If the player obviously don't measure the meaning of the avatar, the penalty can be reduced.		\| Avatar immediate removal + Forbid to chat or publish between 3 days and forever depending on the gravity. In any case: the player should be warn that this is the last warning before ban. If the player obviously don't measure the meaning of the avatar, the penalty can be reduced.
	\|-		\|-
Радок 157:		Радок 160:

	\|}		\|}


	== Details on Avatar policy ==		== Details on Avatar policy ==

Sourisdudesert на 11:57, 5 лютага 2019

2019-02-05T11:57:20Z

← Папярэдн. версія		Версія ад 13:57, 5 лютага 2019
Радок 157:		Радок 157:

	\|}		\|}


			== Details on Avatar policy ==


			What is strictly forbidden is basically everything that may hurt a minor child or is forbidden by the laws:
			* Sexually explicit content (ex: porn, genitals pictures, ...).
			* Extreme violence or shocking images.
			* Explicit reference to drugs,
			* Offensive/vulgar content,


			The following categories are also forbidden, but we may tolerate some of them depending on the context (see below):
			* Advertisements:
			** As a rule of thumb, advertisement is forbidden.
			** However, if it refers to a "cult brand" with no intention to provide a real advertisement (ex: football team), or if the reference to the brand is not obvious or discrete (ex: joke on Apple logo), it may be tolerated.
			** Advertisement for board games publishers / board games in general is authorized.
			** Advertisement for another online gaming service is strictly forbidden.
			* "Sexy" images:
			** If the main purpose of the image is "to be sexy" or "erotic", it is forbidden.
			** However, if the image is a fictional character that is considered sexy (ex: some heroïc fantasy character, super hero, ...), it may be tolerated.
			* Politics / Religion / opinions:
			** Images that refers to extreme positions / provocative ideas are of course forbidden (ex: nazi or other racists symbols).
			** For the others: as a rule of thumb, players should avoid using their avatar to advertise for politics/religion or any other king of opinion. However, if the image is clearly non-shocking for a vast majority of BGA players, it should probably be tolerated.
			* Text on image: our policy about BGA usernames also applied to the text on avatar images.

Sourisdudesert: /* Penalty Grid */

2019-01-21T16:14:11Z

Penalty Grid

← Папярэдн. версія		Версія ад 18:14, 21 студзеня 2019
Радок 117:		Радок 117:
	! Kingmaking		! Kingmaking
	\| Kingmaking action during a game		\| Kingmaking action during a game
	\| The report must contains SEVERAL table id of game with 3+ players (the CANNOT be any kingmaking on 2 players games), the exact moves numbers, and the exact explanation why this is a kingmaking action. To declare a player guilty, the player must have played an obvious move against his own interest, and it has to be a good player (clues: his ELO, number of game played, ...). As the difference between a mistake and a kingmaking action is very tight, one kingmaking report is not enough to find a player guilty: only players who regularly play against their interest should be found guilty. Note that 99% of kingmaking reports are not accurate enough, ~~contains~~ not ~~enough information,~~ and are closed ~~because of this~~.		\| As 99% of kingmaking reports are not accurate enough, we are not ignoring Kingmaking report (and now there are closed automatically). Instead, we've add a "Kingmaking / team play" red thumb category, and we must incite players to use this (Red Thumbs) instead of report these players to moderation.
	~~\| -1~~ to ~~-10 reputation penalty. Moderators should warn the player that~~ this ~~is a only small warning. Relapses can lead~~ to ~~higher reputation points penalties~~.
	\|-		\|-
	! Bug exploit		! Bug exploit

Sourisdudesert: /* Penalty Grid */

2018-11-14T17:18:17Z

Penalty Grid

← Папярэдн. версія		Версія ад 19:18, 14 лістапада 2018
Радок 108:		Радок 108:
	\| Inappropriate username		\| Inappropriate username
	\| If needed, report author should explain why this is inappropriate. Username are inappropriate when this is obviously an insult for many people. Moderators shouldn't moderate a username that is insulting by accident in a language that is not widely used on BGA.		\| If needed, report author should explain why this is inappropriate. Username are inappropriate when this is obviously an insult for many people. Moderators shouldn't moderate a username that is insulting by accident in a language that is not widely used on BGA.
	\| ~~Ban from the website. Moderators should~~ explain that ~~the player~~ is ~~welcome with another~~ username ~~on BGA~~. ~~Note that if~~ the ~~player has a long seniority on BGA~~ (=~~many games played), moderators should be very cautious on the case: if no one noticed the username until now, it is probably not inappropriate~~.		\| Same as insult + Report author must explain that a username change is mandatory from "Preferences / Account / Account Management / Change my username. If there is another report 48 hours after the first one with no name change (or another insulting username) => ban forever.
	\|-		\|-
	! Table description		! Table description